Cantharellus formosus Look-alikes
Cantharellus cibarius var. roseocanus (above left), has a frosty pinkish cap margin when young, a bright yellow-orange fertile underside (hymenium), lacks fibrils or scales on the cap, and does not turn immediately yellow when bruised or cut. Cantharellus formosus (above right), has a dirty orange cap with closely adhering scales (usually visible only in dry weather), a pale pinkish orange hymenium, and immediately turns yellow to yellow-orange when bruised or cut.
Paxillus involutus (above), (sometimes also called the “brown” chanterelle”), lacks orange colours, has thin true gills rather than folds, strongly inrolled bearded margins, and the entire mushrooms stains brown. Gomphus kauffmanii (above), and pale forms of G. floccosus have deeply hollowed fruiting bodies that are vase-shaped, have scaly caps and pale shallow hymenia.
Hygrophoropsis aurantiaca, (above), the false chanterelle, has a light orange to orange brown cap, has bright orange thin gills instead of folds, has a less fleshy, more fragile stature than C. formosus, and grows on visible or buried decayed wood. It causes brown rot of trees. Hydnum repandum (above), or H. umbilicatum the edible hedgehog, and H. umbilicatum, the belly button mushroom, both have fertile spines or teeth instead of ridges or folds.
Chroogomphus tomentosus (above), the woolly pine spike, is a bright orange, unpolished, velvety mushroom, with thick, widely spaced orange true gills that turn brownish black with age. The spore print is black.