Tricholoma magnivelare Look-alikes
Tricholoma calligatum (top left, top right) has more and darker (purplish-brown) fibrils on the cap and stipe and it is not as robust as T. magnivelare (bottom left and bottom right).
Amanita smithiana (above), is a poisonous mushroom that grows in the same environment as Tricholoma magnivelare, is white, has a cottony, white cap with cottony scales that often hang down at the margins, has a more slender aspect and turnip-shaped rooting stipe. Catathelasma ventricosa (above), and its larger cousin C. imperialis, lack the pine mushroom's distinctive spicy, cinnamon odour and have decurrent (instead of notched) gills.
Russula brevipe (above), has brittle flesh, lacks an annulus around the stalk, is odourless, and has horizontal to decurrent unnotched gills. Hygrophorus subalpinus (above), found most frequently in the spring near melting snow (but also in summer and fall), has soft waxy decurrent gills, a fleeting membranous annulus that when present is found at the base of the stipe close to ground, and an indistinct odour.
Tricholoma focale (Armillaria zelleri) (above), which can produce serious digestive upsets, has a bright orange cap and lacks the distinctive spicy cinnamon odour of T. magniverlare